In this episode, Dr. Rob Harter sits down with Michael Thatcher, CEO of Charity Navigator, to explore how the nation’s largest independent charity evaluator is evolving to better serve donors and nonprofits alike. With over a decade at the helm, Michael shares how his background in technology and impact measurement has shaped Charity Navigator’s shift toward a more comprehensive, 360-degree view of nonprofit effectiveness.
From financial transparency and governance best practices to measuring real impact and rebuilding trust in the nonprofit sector, this conversation dives deep into how data-informed giving can strengthen both donor confidence and organizational performance. Whether you’re a nonprofit executive striving for a higher rating or a donor seeking to invest in meaningful change, this episode provides practical insights to help you give—and lead—smarter.
Key Topics Include:
- The mission of Charity Navigator and how it has expanded to rate over 250,000 nonprofits
- Why overhead is not a proxy for impact—and how to think beyond simple financial ratios
- Best practices for improving your nonprofit’s rating, including governance, transparency, and data submission
- How Charity Navigator’s new 360-degree rating system evaluates organizational health and impact
- The importance of transparency, independent boards, and posting your IRS Form 990
- Why donors should think of their giving as an investment in impact, not just a charitable transaction
- Addressing declining trust in the nonprofit sector and the role of third-party evaluators in rebuilding confidence
Mentioned in This Episode:
This Episode is Sponsored By:
Links to Resources:
- Interested in Leadership and Life Coaching? Visit Rob’s website: RobHarter.com
- Find us on YouTube: Nonprofit Leadership Podcast YouTube Channel
- Suggestions for the show? Email us at nonprofitleadershippodcast@gmail.com
- Request a sample coaching session: Email Rob at rob@robharter.com
Subscribe and Share
Listen and subscribe to the Nonprofit Leadership Podcast on iTunes, Spotify, or Amazon. Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and share with other nonprofit leaders!
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Subscribe: RSS